Practical Guide · Discrimination Evidence
Building Your Evidence File for a California Discrimination Case: A Practical Guide for Workers
You probably do not have a confession from your boss. Most people who bring these cases never do, and many may have more proof than they think.
A discrimination case usually rests on a collection of smaller facts rather than one decisive document: dated notes, your own pay and review records, messages you were part of, the names of people who saw what happened, and signs that coworkers outside your group were treated better. Start that file now, keep it outside work accounts where you lawfully can, and leave confidential company material where it is.
For a review of what you have gathered, we recommend the workplace discrimination lawyers at Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights, a California firm that represents workers only.
Think of your evidence file as a folder you add to a little at a time. No single piece has to prove the case; together, they can show a pattern that is hard to explain away.
A California Employee Has Rights Under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA)
Evidence is measured against a legal standard. California's Fair Employment and Housing Act generally applies to employers with five or more employees for discrimination, and its harassment protections reach employers of any size. LFECR's glossary gives an overview of FEHA claims in California.
Employment discrimination can be based on a protected characteristic under FEHA
The core question in most cases is why something happened. Discrimination generally means an adverse decision, such as a firing, demotion, pay cut or denied promotion, made because of a protected characteristic. The glossary entry on workplace discrimination explains the idea in plain terms.
Protected characteristics under FEHA include race, gender, age, disability, pregnancy, religion and national origin
That list is only a start. Protected characteristics generally also include color, ancestry, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex (including childbirth and related conditions), gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, and military and veteran status, among others. Race generally includes traits such as hair texture and protective hairstyles, religion generally covers religious dress and grooming, disability can be physical or mental, and age protection generally applies to workers 40 and over.
Direct Versus Circumstantial Evidence
Direct evidence
- A statement tying the decision to the characteristic
- For example, a manager writing that a role needs "someone younger"
- Rare, because most employers know not to say it
Circumstantial evidence
- Facts that, taken together, point to the real reason
- Timing, comparisons, changing explanations, skipped policies
- The kind of proof most cases generally rest on
No Smoking Gun? Here Is What Usually Carries a Case
If you have no admission, you are in the usual position, not a hopeless one. Look for these kinds of facts:
- Comments or slurs connected to the characteristic, even ones passed off as jokes.
- Better treatment of coworkers outside your group in similar situations, such as the same mistake drawing a warning for them and a firing for you.
- Timing, such as an adverse action soon after the employer learned of a pregnancy, a disability or a complaint.
- Shifting explanations, where the stated reason changes or does not match the record.
- Skipped policies, where the employer did not follow its own discipline or review process.
- A sudden turn after a history of good reviews.
- Patterns affecting others in the same group.
What to Write Down and Keep
- Notes made at the timeFor each incident, record the date, who was involved, what was said or done, where it happened and who saw it. Notes written close to the event tend to be more reliable.
- Your own recordsKeep your pay stubs, schedules, performance reviews, offer letter and any discipline you received.
- Messages you were part ofSave texts and emails sent to you or by you that relate to the treatment.
- A running list of witnessesNames, roles and what each person saw or heard.
Store copies outside work accounts and devices where it is lawful to do so, since access to a work account can end without warning.
Can I Take Documents From Work?
Be careful here. Do not take confidential or privileged company documents, other people's private information, or anything from systems you are not authorized to use. Doing so can create problems of its own. If you are unsure whether you may keep something, ask a lawyer before you copy it.
Do Witnesses Matter?
Often, yes. A coworker who heard a comment or was treated differently can back up your notes. You do not need to ask anyone to take sides now; just note who was present.
Do I Need to Complain Internally First?
Generally, no. An internal complaint is not usually required before filing with the state. Reporting through your employer's process can still help, because it creates a dated record and may matter to some defenses an employer raises. Retaliation for complaining about discrimination is generally unlawful under FEHA as well.
What Happens With the Civil Rights Department?
Before filing a FEHA lawsuit, a worker generally files a complaint with the California Civil Rights Department (CRD, formerly the Department of Fair Employment and Housing) and receives a right-to-sue notice. Deadlines apply to that step, so do not wait long. The courts' self-help center explains general court procedures if a case later moves to court.
Does It Cost Money to Talk to a Lawyer?
Not with our featured firm. Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights offers a free case review, according to its site, and works on contingency, meaning no fee unless there is a recovery. If you would like to compare options, the State Bar lists certified lawyer referral services.
- Practice focus
- Discrimination, retaliation, whistleblower, wage and hour and misclassification claims
- Clients
- Employees and consumers only, never employers
- Fees
- Contingency; no recovery, no fee
- Headquarters
- Burbank, Los Angeles County; the firm says it serves all 58 California counties
- Languages
- English and Spanish
McKay Law Office publishes this guide as general information about evidence in California discrimination cases. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Which evidence matters depends on the facts of each case, and no outcome is guaranteed. Speak with a qualified California employment attorney about your own situation.