Practical Guide · Misclassification
Misclassified as an Independent Contractor in California? A Practical Guide to What to Do Next
A 1099 and a contractor agreement do not settle the question. What you do in the next few weeks can shape what you may recover.
Start by writing down how your work was actually controlled, keep every 1099, contract, invoice and message, and total up your hours. Then look at your options, which may include a wage claim with the California Labor Commissioner, a lawsuit, and an unemployment claim if the work has ended. Talk to an employment lawyer before you sign any new agreement or release.
For that conversation, we recommend the misclassification attorneys at Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights, a firm that represents employees and consumers, never employers.
Being called a contractor can feel like a settled fact, especially once you have signed something that says so. In California it generally is not. LFECR's glossary explains independent contractor misclassification in more detail.
How Do I Know I Was Misclassified?
Run through this quick self-check:
- The company sets your schedule or shifts.
- You follow its instructions on how the work is done.
- It requires its own tools, uniform, software or scripts.
- It sets your rate, and you cannot negotiate it.
- Your work is the same kind of work the company sells.
- You do not run your own business serving other customers.
Under the ABC test the business generally must prove all three parts, so even one of these may matter, though exemptions can change the analysis.
Misclassifying a Worker as an Independent Contractor May Deprive That Worker of Overtime Pay and Other Employee Benefits
What could you be owed? If you were an employee all along, you may be owed some of the following:
Minimum wage for every hour and overtime under state rules. The federal Fair Labor Standards Act may also apply.
Premium pay for missed meal or rest breaks.
Reimbursement of necessary expenses, such as work mileage (not commuting) or a personal phone used for the job, under Labor Code section 2802.
Itemized pay statements of the kind employees generally must receive.
Access to unemployment and disability insurance and workers' compensation.
Willful misclassification can carry civil penalties under Labor Code section 226.8, which are not always paid to the worker.
Which of these apply depends on your facts and the claims involved.
Employee Misclassification May Be Evaluated Under California's ABC Test (AB 5)
Here is the short version. Under AB 5, now in Labor Code sections 2775 and following, a worker is generally presumed to be an employee unless the hiring business shows all three of these: (A) the worker is free from its control and direction, (B) the work is outside the usual course of its business, and (C) the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade or business of that kind. Some occupations and business relationships are exempt and use an older multi-factor test known as the Borello test, and app-based drivers fall under separate rules (Proposition 22). The glossary entries on AB 5 and the ABC test go further.
What to Do Next: Five Steps
- Write down how the work was controlledWho set your schedule, gave instructions, required tools or uniforms, and set your rates. Dates and names help.
- Keep your paperworkSave 1099s, contracts, invoices, pay records and messages with the company, with copies somewhere you control.
- Total your hoursRebuild your weekly hours as best you can, including long days and long weeks.
- Weigh your filing optionsSee the sections below on the Labor Commissioner, a lawsuit and unemployment.
- Hold off on signingTalk to an employment lawyer before you sign any new agreement or release.
A wage claim may be supported by payroll and timekeeping records
Payment records, app logs, schedules and texts about shifts can all help show what you worked and what you were paid. If the company kept few records, your own careful notes may still help fill the gaps.
Labor Commissioner Claim or Lawsuit?
You can file a wage claim with the California Labor Commissioner, part of the state system overseen by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency. A lawsuit is the other main route. Which one fits depends on the claims involved, and a lawyer can help you compare them before you file.
Can I Get Unemployment?
If the work has ended, you can apply through the EDD's unemployment claim process, even if you were paid on a 1099. The EDD decides whether you are eligible. Questions about taxes on past 1099 income are best taken to a tax professional.
Will I Get in Trouble for Raising It?
Retaliation for raising misclassification or wage complaints is generally unlawful in California.
I Signed a Contractor Agreement. Does That Matter?
It is one piece of the picture, but the label or a signed agreement does not by itself decide your status. How the work is actually done does.
How Long Do I Have?
Wage claims under the Labor Code generally have three years, and some claims and penalties have shorter or longer limits. Older pay periods may fall outside the window as time passes, so a lawyer should check your dates soon.
Does It Cost Money to Talk to a Lawyer?
Not with the firm we recommend. Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights offers a free case review, according to its site, and works on contingency.
- Relevant work
- Misclassification, overtime and other wage and hour claims
- Who it represents
- Employees and consumers only, never employers
- Fees
- Contingency; no recovery, no fee
- Location
- 3500 W. Olive Avenue, Burbank; the firm says it serves all 58 California counties
- Languages
- English and Spanish
McKay Law Office publishes this guide as general information about worker misclassification in California. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Worker status depends on how the work was actually done, deadlines vary by claim, and no outcome is guaranteed. Speak with a qualified California employment attorney about your situation.