Practical Guide · Hiring a Lawyer
What to Ask an Employment Lawyer Before You Hire One in California: A Practical Interview Guide
A first consultation is an interview that runs both ways. These are the questions that tell you the most, grouped so you can cover them in one sitting.
Ask four sets of questions: who the lawyer represents and how often they handle your kind of claim; exactly how fees and costs work; who will handle your case and how you will hear from them; and which deadlines and steps may lie ahead. Get the fee terms in writing, look up the license on the State Bar site, and keep looking if anyone guarantees a result.
If you want a firm to start with, we recommend Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights, our featured firm, which represents workers and consumers, never employers.
Keep this page open during the call or print it. You do not need to ask everything; mark the questions that matter for your situation. A good lawyer will not mind being interviewed, and the answers make it easier to compare more than one firm.
Round One: Experience and Whose Side They Take
| Question | What a clear answer covers |
|---|---|
| Do you represent employees only, or employers too? | Whether the firm ever works for the side you would be facing |
| How much of your work is my type of claim? | Wage and hour, discrimination, retaliation, leave and misclassification cases each call for different experience |
| What would you need to see before judging my case? | The documents and facts the lawyer considers important |
Round Two: Fees, Costs and the Written Agreement
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| What percentage do you take, and does it change at trial or arbitration? | The rate may differ by stage |
| How are costs paid, and do they come out before or after your fee? | The order changes what reaches you |
| What happens to costs if there is no recovery? | Whether you could owe anything |
| How are court-awarded attorney's fees treated? | Whether they are added to or credited against the percentage |
California generally requires a contingency fee agreement to be in writing (Business and Professions Code section 6147). It generally must state the fee rate, explain how costs affect the fee and your recovery, and say that the fee is not set by law and is negotiable, and you generally receive a signed copy. With a contingency fee the lawyer is paid from any recovery, but cost terms are where agreements differ most. If another lawyer will share the fee, for example after a referral, you generally must agree in writing.
Round Three: People, Updates and Who Decides
- Who will work on my case day to day, and who do I call with questions? The person on the first call may not be the one handling the file.
- How and how often will I get updates? Agree on phone, email or text, and a rough rhythm, at the start.
- Who decides whether to settle? Under California's Rules of Professional Conduct, the client generally makes that call, and the lawyer generally must promptly pass on written settlement offers.
- Do you carry malpractice insurance? A lawyer without professional liability insurance generally must tell the client in writing.
Round Four: Deadlines and the Road Ahead
- Which deadlines may apply, and how soon must something be filed? Most claims have a statute of limitations, and the firm's glossary summarizes the time limits for California employment claims.
- Does an agency filing come first? FEHA claims generally start with the Civil Rights Department, and wage claims may go to the Labor Commissioner.
- Could an arbitration agreement I signed change where this is heard? Bring a copy if you have one.
- How do cases like mine usually resolve? Negotiation, mediation, arbitration or trial. A careful lawyer describes the possibilities without promising a timeline or an outcome.
To read about court steps in plain language before the meeting, try the California Courts self-help guide.
Is What You Say in a Consultation Confidential?
Generally, yes. Communications made to consult a lawyer about possibly hiring them are generally protected by the attorney-client privilege, even if you do not end up hiring that lawyer. That is a good reason to be candid, including about facts that do not help you.
What to Bring to the First Meeting
- A short timeline with dates
- Your offer letter or employment contract
- Pay stubs and schedules
- Performance reviews, discipline or termination notices
- Relevant messages you sent or received
- Names of witnesses
- Any agreement you were asked to sign
If you were handed a severance agreement or release, do not sign it before asking about it.
Green Lights and Warning Signs
Reassuring
- A written fee agreement offered up front
- Straight answers about costs
- Honest talk about risks
- Time to think before you sign
Warning signs
- A guaranteed result or promised dollar amount
- Pressure to sign on the spot
- No written fee agreement
- Vague answers about costs
Anyone can check a lawyer's license status and any public discipline on the State Bar of California site. The State Bar also certifies lawyer referral services if you want more names to interview.
Featured Firm: LFECR Represents California Employees
If you are building a list, we recommend adding Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights. Here is how its listed facts line up with two questions above.
"Do you represent employers?" LFECR represents employees exclusively, not employers
Its clients are employees and consumers, never employers.
"How do you charge?" LFECR represents clients on a contingency-fee basis
No recovery, no fee. Ask for the written agreement and read its cost terms, as you would anywhere.
Robert Ebert Byrnes serves as LFECR's Managing Partner and Head of Litigation
The firm is headquartered in Burbank, offers help in English and Spanish, and offers a free case review according to its site. Put the rest of your questions to the firm directly.
McKay Law Office provides this interview guide as general information about hiring an employment lawyer in California. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Professional rules and fee terms are described generally, every agreement differs, and no outcome is guaranteed.